The beauty of Dynasty Fantasy Football is that there are no clear-cut answers. People strategize differently, build rosters differently, have different goals for their teams, and most importantly, value players differently. When you play in single-season Fantasy Football Leagues, the answers are all in front of you. The players who score the most points for that single season are the most valuable, and that is it. That is not the case for Dynasty Leagues, and it’s even more complex for Dynasty SuperFlex Leagues.
Some managers play in “win now” mode, some managers play looking two to three years out, some play five or more years out, and others are some sort of mix. This creates gaps in how Fantasy managers value individual players, which typically will align somewhere with their team’s need, build, and direction. Due to the complexity of valuation, a lot of managers struggle with truly understanding some sort of universal Dynasty value for individual players. That is where I come in for this article.
I will highlight my top 12 most valuable Dynasty players for SuperFlex formats. Super Flex formats are leagues where you can technically start two quarterbacks, so the value of quarterbacks is significantly higher than your standard one-quarterback league. This is also focused on points per reception (PPR) leagues. Let’s get it
Skrip’s Top 12 Dynasty Fantasy Football SuperFlex Players
12. Amon-Ra St. Brown (WR, Lions)
ARSB has felt like one of the safest wide receivers to roster the last three seasons: hyper-targeted, yardage productive, monster after-the-catch, and a scorer of Fantasy Points. 18.6 (2024) and 20.7 (2023) Fantasy points per game (PPG) the last two seasons have been dominant, and ranked #4 for the position in each of those years. St. Brown did regress in targets (164 to 142), receptions (119 to 115), and receiving yards (1,515 to 1,263) this year, but scored two more touchdowns (12) than the previous year. Even with the likes of Jameson Williams and Sam LaPorta to compete against for targets, ARSB is still the clear alpha through the air in a great Detroit offense with consistent WR1 overall upside.
11. Jahmyr Gibbs (RB, Lions)
As a rookie, Jahmyr Gibbs’ 16.1 Fantasy PPG ranked 8th for the position despite ranking 28th in carries (182). David Montgomery missed some time in 2024, but all credit goes to Gibbs for his leap in production. 250 carries for 1,412 rushing yards, 52 catches (second year in a row) for 517 receiving yards, and a massive 20 total touchdowns. 21.4 Fantasy PPG in 2024 ranked second for the position. Even with a healthy David Montgomery you can count on Gibbs to be utilized like a true weapon in a stellar Detroit offense, with upside in both rushing and receiving with a huge boost due to touchdowns.
10. Bijan Robinson (RB, Falcons)
Deemed a generational talent, Bijan Robinson was selected eighth overall by the Falcons in 2023. Bijan did not necessarily live up to the hype his rookie season vs. expectations, but “he was who we thought he is” in 2024. Bijan rushed 304 times for 1,456 yards, caught 61 balls for 431 yards, scored 15 total touchdowns, and averaged 20.1 Fantasy PPG (#3). This was a full-blown workhorse who had explosive weeks for Fantasy, in an offense that was still figuring itself out in 2024. The upside for Gibbs and Bijan is very similar but my difference is the lack of a David Montgomery cutting into Bijan’s workload.
9. Brock Bowers (TE, Raiders)
The greatest rookie tight end prospect had the greatest tight end NFL rookie season. It is as simple as that. The scary part? Brock Bowers exploded onto the scene with a combination of mediocre talent at the quarterback position with the likes of Gardner Minshew, Aidan O’Connell, and Desmond Ridder. 153 targets, 112 receptions (NFL rookie record), 1,194 receiving yards (NFL tight end rookie record), five touchdowns, and 15.3 Fantasy PPG resulted in a TE1 overall Fantasy finish in 2024. Bowers now has an upgrade at quarterback with veteran Geno Smith for 2025. If you roster Bowers, you have a clear advantage in Fantasy Football, likely for a decade.
8. Malik Nabers (WR, Giants)
The Giants spent the sixth overall draft pick on Makik Nabers in 2024, and he was well worth that investment and some. 170 targets were the second most, 109 receptions were the third most, 1,204 receiving yards ranked seventh, he scored seven touchdowns, and averaged 18.2 (#6) Fantasy PPG in 2024. Nabers was so productive with the likes of Daniel Jones, Drew Lock, Tommy DeVito, and Tim Boyle last year, which is a very average at best core. Nabers now has not one but two upgrades at quarterback for 2025 in Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston. Nabers proved to be one of the league’s most dominant receivers as a rookie, and the sky is truly the limit for him moving forward.
7. Justin Jefferson (WR, Vikings)
Justin Jefferson has done nothing but dominate through five NFL seasons. Through Jefferson’s career, he has averaged 145.8 targets, 99 catches, 1,486.4 receiving yards, eight touchdowns, and 19.42 Fantasy PPG. If we remove the 10-game season, those averages jump to 157.2 targets, 106.75 catches, 1,589.5 receiving yards, and 8.75 touchdowns. Jefferson has had a mixture of quarterbacks but primarily played with Kirk Cousins and Sam Darnold, so a competent JJ McCarthy in 2025 should not worry anyone. Jordan Addison has proven to be a great complement to JJ.
6. Ja’Marr Chase (WR, Bengals)
The Ja’Marr Chase and Joe Burrow LSU turned Bengals connection is the best in the NFL, and we saw that in 2024. 175 targets, 127 receptions, 1,708 receiving yards, 17 touchdowns, and 23.7 (#1) Fantasy PPG was beyond dominant in 2024. 2024 was the first time both Chase and Burrow were healthy for a full season since Chase’s rookie year in 2021, where he produced 1,455 receiving yards, 13 touchdowns, and 17.9 Fantasy PPG (#5). Even with Tee Higgins, Chase should continue to be a heavy favorite to break Fantasy on a yearly basis. Chase checks all boxes.
5. Jalen Hurts (QB, Eagles)
Jalen Hurts has averaged over 21 Fantasy PPG for four straight years now, with his most dominant year being in 2022, where he averaged 25.6 Fantasy PPG. Hurts may lack the upside in the passing statistics, but he has thrived in the Eagles’ offense, which featured Saquon Barkley, AJ Brown, DeVonta Smith, Dallas Goedert, and even Jahan Dotson in a Super Bowl-winning 2024 season. Hurts has ranged from 605-782 rushing yards the last four seasons with rushing touchdown totals of 14, 15, 13, and 10 during these seasons. Great weapons, a great offensive line, and major upside make Hurts a dominant asset at the quarterback position.
4. Joe Burrow (QB, Bengals)
Joe Burrow has now had three seasons averaging over 20 Fantasy PPG, with his most dominant year being 2024. Burrow threw the ball 652 times (#1) for 4,918 passing yards (#1) and 43 passing touchdowns (#1) in 2024, which resulted in 22.5 (#3) Fantasy PPG. Burrow is the epitome of arm talent, with arguably the most upside through the air in the league for Fantasy Football. The Burrow-Chase connection is the best in football, but the combination of Burrow-Chase-Tee Higgins is the best trio in the NFL on top of that. Burrow had an argument for the MVP in 2024, and is a candidate for that sort of award yearly. Talent paired with weapons and an offense that lets Joey B rip it is massive for Fantasy.
3. Josh Allen (QB, Bills)
2024 meant an MVP Award for Josh Allen: 483 passing attempts, 3,731 passing yards, 28 passing touchdowns, 531 rushing yards, and 12 rushing touchdowns. Allen has finished four seasons with over 4,300 passing yards, ranging from 510 to 776 rushing yards in six seasons, and has totaled 27 rushing touchdowns the last two years. For the position, Allen has finished #2, #1, #3, #1, #1 in Fantasy PPG the last five seasons, ranging from 22.7 to 25.4 PPG in all of them. Allen and Fantasy Football dominance go hand in hand.
2. Lamar Jackson (QB, Ravens)
Lamar Jackson just feels like a video game character in the Fantasy Football world, and his 25.6 Fantasy PPG in 2024 speaks to that. In 2024 Jackson had career-highs in passing with 474 attempts for 4,172 passing yards and 41 passing touchdowns. 915 rushing yards led the position for the year but ranked third for his career behind the 1,005 in 2020 and the 1,213 in 2019. Back in 2019, Jackson averaged a massive 28.2 Fanatsy PPG, so the ceiling is massive. 2024 featured a combination of Derrick Henry, Zay Flowers, Mark Andrews, and Rashod Bateman with DeAndre Hopkins now added this off-season. LJ makes it look easy, and he is second to none.
1. Jayden Daniels (QB, Commanders)
This is a spicy ranking to put Jayden Daniels #1 after just one year in the NFL, but I have a big question to start this off with: if many view Daniels as in the same tier as Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen then why would you not want someone four+ years younger for the next decade on your team? 480 passing attempts, 3,568 passing yards, 25 passing touchdowns, 891 rushing yards, and six rushing touchdowns meant 21.5 Fantasy PPG (#5) as a rookie for the Commanders. Many have voiced a fear for a CJ Stroud year-two dropoff but when you rush like Daniels (Stroud does not rush), then that should not be a similar instance. Daniels was absolutely dominant in 2024 and just one game away from a Super Bowl appearance. Washington added Deebo Samuel to Terry McLaurin this off-season, who provides some stat-boosting potential for Daniels due to his yard-after-catch upside. Washington will continue to build around Daniels, and in SuperFlex leagues, you might get a decade of big relevance out of this guy. Argue with a wall.
You can also check out my Dynasty Football Rankings for more traditional formats.
