The Home of Fantasy Sports Analysis

50 Hitters Who Gain Value in OBP Leagues, Plus Top 250 OBP Rankings

The Tout Wars Draft and Hold is underway and it got me all in an OBP frame of mind. I recently shared my draft strategy for that league and part of it involved focusing on the OBP vs. AVG aspect. I’m probably not gonna get a huge bump against the field in that league, but in typical OBP leagues recognizing the players who gain and lose value due to the format, change can be invaluable.

In his recent post in search of Points League Hitting Values, our own Michael Florio coined the term Roto Bias, referring to the over-reliance on Rotisserie Baseball Rankings even when an owner is in a Points League. Following his lead, I’m gonna use this post to point out the 5X5 Bias that you might be able to take advantage of in OBP Leagues.

Most fantasy baseball rankings you’ll find are geared toward the traditional 5X5 categories that include AVG, Runs, HR, RBI, and SB on the hitting side. Many owners don’t take the time to calculate or even search out rankings with OBP taken into account. I’ll have a set of rankings for OBP Leagues out very soon. This post is just intended to point out the hitters who gain and lose the most value in points league. You get it. Let’s get on with it Doug.


What?! Your league is not planning on using Fantrax? Inconceivable! Check out everything Fantrax has to offer and I’m sure you’ll come around to our way of thinking.


50 Hitters Who Gain Value in OBP Leagues

The table below uses 2019 statistics of all hitters with 150+ at-bats. The rankings column IS NOT how I would rank these hitters in an OBP league. Instead, it ranks the players on the largest differentials between that player’s batting average and on-base percentage. You can see each player’s stats for those respective categories in the three columns to the right. Feel free to ignore some of the names on this first table. Alex Avila is nothing more than a second catcher in AL-Only OBP leagues. Derek Dietrich may be of interest in deep leagues if he somehow gets enough playing time, but his .187 AVG and .328 OBP were huge negatives in 2019. You get the idea.

To see the hitters who lose the most value in OBP leagues keep scrolling further down the page.

Diff RnkPlayerAVGOBPDiff
1Brandon Nimmo.221.375.154
2Mike Trout.291.438.147
3Alex Avila.207.353.146
4Derek Dietrich.187.328.141
5Rhys Hoskins.226.364.138
6Joey Gallo.253.389.136
7Justin Smoak.208.342.134
8Yasmani Grandal.246.380.134
9Daniel Vogelbach.208.341.133
10Jake Lamb.193.323.130
11Cavan Biggio.234.364.130
12Alex Bregman.296.423.127
13Travis Shaw.157.281.124
14Chance Sisco.210.333.123
15Max Muncy.251.374.123
16Mark Canha.273.396.123
17Andrew McCutchen.256.378.122
18Josh Donaldson.259.379.120
19Mark Reynolds.170.290.120
20Juan Soto.282.401.119
21Kendrys Morales.194.313.119
22Russell Martin.220.337.117
23Carlos Santana.281.397.116
24Greg Garcia.248.364.116
25Luke Voit.263.378.115
26Matt Joyce.295.408.113
27Anthony Rizzo.293.405.112
28Bryce Harper.260.372.112
29Harrison Bader.205.314.109
30Aaron Judge.272.381.109
31Robinson Chirinos.238.347.109
32Matt Carpenter.226.334.108
33Dexter Fowler.238.346.108
34Tyler Austin.188.296.108
35Tim Locastro.250.357.107
36Luis Urias.223.329.106
37Michael Conforto.257.363.106
38Shin-Soo Choo.265.371.106
39Brandon Belt.234.339.105
40Andrew Knapp.213.318.105
41David Bote.257.362.105
42Carson Kelly.245.348.103
43Jeimer Candelario.203.306.103
44Brian Dozier.238.340.102
45Ji-Man Choi.261.363.102
46Derek Fisher.185.287.102
47Cody Bellinger.305.406.101
48Kris Bryant.282.382.100
49Jason Castro.232.332.100
50Christian Yelich.329.429.100

25 Hitters Who Lose Value in OBP Leagues

I followed the same process here, but I took out the players no one in their right mind would be drafting in any league regardless of format. These are the name players that will likely be over-drafted in OBP Leagues.

Diff RnkPlayerAVGOBPDiff
408Tim Anderson.335.357.022
407Eddie Rosario.276.300.024
406Hanser Alberto.305.329.024
404Kevin Pillar.259.287.028
403Adalberto Mondesi.263.291.028
402Dee Gordon.275.304.029
398Starlin Castro.270.300.030
389Victor Reyes.304.336.032
382Anthony Santander.261.297.036
381Freddy Galvis.260.296.036
378Amed Rosario.287.323.036
375Elvis Andrus.275.313.038
374Didi Gregorius.238.276.038
371Giovanny Urshela.314.355.041
370Danny Santana.283.324.041
368Yadier Molina.270.312.042
366Jean Segura.280.323.043
362Christian Vazquez.276.320.044
359Eric Hosmer.265.310.045
356Andrelton Simmons.264.309.045
353Yuli Gurriel.298.343.045
350Whit Merrifield.302.348.046
349Tommy Edman.304.350.046
347Jose Abreu.284.330.046
345Bo Bichette.311.358.047

OBP Notes

Here are a few takeaways from looking over these tables.

  • There may be an argument over the No. 1 pick in 5X5 leagues, but Mike Trout is a no-brainer in OBP Leagues.
  • If Brandon Nimmo ever stays healthy he could easily be a Top-3 round pick in this format.
  • Joey Gallo, welcome to the elite hitter club!
  • Is Cavan Biggio fantasy baseball’s biggest sleeper in OBP Leagues?
  • Carlos Santana will help that first base position get a little less thin.
  • Kris Bryant gets a big boost and a healthy season with a return of his full power looks pretty nice.
  • Tim Anderson likely played over his head in 2019 anyway. In OBP formats he’s way down the shortstop rankings.
  • Eddie Rosario a sleeper? That .300 OBP says otherwise.
  • Not only is Dee Gordon a one-trick pony, but his OBP trick negates most of his potential value in stolen bases.
  • Adalberto Mondesi in the first two rounds? Slow your roll!
  • Didi Gregorius may have a bounce-back season in Philly, but that OBP better be filled with super balls.

Top 250 Hitter Rankings for OBP Leagues

I’ve had a couple of people ask me for complete rankings for OBP formats, so here they are. I did not include the pitchers as nothing changes in the value relationship between hitters and pitchers. It’s still a matter of preference and strategy when and where you draft each. The statistics below are from my last projection run, which was a couple of weeks back, so they may not reflect the latest news on a few players. Feel free to adjust accordingly.

RNKNAMEPOSPAABHHRRRBIBBSOSBAVGOBPSLG
1Mike TroutOF6385091534510710811512112.300.429.634
2Ronald Acuna Jr.OF685599166391111067517127.277.358.526
3Christian YelichOF623526159351011038713123.302.401.572
4Cody Bellinger1B648558162431051078412312.290.383.594
5Mookie BettsOF70760918431124958810618.302.391.541
6Jose Ramirez3B646566160329296718425.282.362.533
7Juan SotoOF6785681673610510810214210.294.401.554
8Bryce HarperOF6825631483610211310917112.264.383.520
9Trevor StorySS65158416836101985916921.287.352.548
10Nolan Arenado3B66759118240100113671072.307.378.577
11Francisco LindorSS69062217734109865910021.284.346.519
12Rafael Devers3B67661817733112114531298.287.344.524
13Trea TurnerSS6295731601898685011338.279.338.454
14Adalberto MondesiSS5935581411581783016649.253.291.416
15Fernando Tatis Jr.SS6265651533297865017525.271.330.512
16Yordan AlvarezOF6385491534296108831592.278.373.577
17Freddie Freeman1B6745831693294105811255.290.377.524
18J.D. MartinezOF6365511613797118761401.292.378.565
19Anthony Rendon3B6425501682810010377904.306.392.543
20Pete Alonso1B6635681454391106801790.254.346.545
21Joey GalloOF611518123449295852146.237.345.553
22Matt Olson1B6635851514491109661721.259.334.538
23Jonathan Villar2B6475821531991655815534.262.329.422
24Alex BregmanSS6795731633210210288955.284.380.520
25Kris Bryant3B6535561583310488781504.283.372.540
26Javier BaezSS643604170331001033417013.282.320.527
27Jose Altuve2B6375781802910181518913.311.367.533
28Marcus SemienSS6946131722799907610412.282.361.482
29Vladimir Guerrero Jr.3B662591177338999661061.299.370.529
30Starling MarteOF6195741672393793110525.290.327.482
31Charlie BlackmonOF6846181873311389551234.302.359.549
32Xander BogaertsSS69361417727104111691254.288.360.507
33Victor RoblesOF6205641522087683713033.269.315.455
34Austin MeadowsOF6465721583288946514210.276.350.519
35Aaron JudgeOF568476130388982851703.273.383.568
36George SpringerOF6345581523310592631337.272.346.505
37Max Muncy2B579483124369294871513.258.371.533
38Josh Donaldson3B624522134328690941503.257.370.503
39Carlos Santana1B66355714829938999992.265.377.479
40Ozzie Albies2B67961617725102865411515.288.346.494
41Rhys Hoskins1B653541131348491981632.243.359.498
42Gleyber TorresSS638576162369598511404.281.340.526
43Michael ConfortoOF627533140348991821445.262.360.509
44Keston Hiura2B6385751563096895116613.271.330.505
45Cavan Biggio2B6215221312488749316816.250.364.448
46Paul Goldschmidt1B652560145298995851563.260.357.464
47Anthony Rizzo1B61251414427869573894.279.369.498
48Marcell OzunaOF630563152328598631266.271.344.494
49Bo BichetteSS6455871662795715213616.283.341.500
50Eloy JimenezOF6475871673891102521550.284.342.532
51Josh Bell1B622537146328693751180.271.360.522
52Whit Merrifield2B6746161811794734710822.293.343.453
53Trey Mancini1B668596165329892601471.276.343.503
54pppp Sano3B541471118388191651840.250.341.544
55Matt Chapman3B663585152339395661591.260.335.511
56Manny MachadoSS651576158338590651176.274.348.497
57Uegenio Suarez3B580503133347892641512.264.347.518
58Gary SanchezC544475117377384601440.246.330.521
59Kyle SchwarberOF597518133388193721552.257.347.534
60Jose Abreu1B6676091723387105401332.282.327.512
61Yasmani GrandalC565468117286873901302.251.372.493
62Ramon LaureanoOF5795201432793784015014.275.327.506
63Edwin Encarnacion1B554477120377491671280.251.343.528
64J.T. RealmutoC571520144248586401145.277.329.489
65Nelson CruzDH5915141353683100651541.262.345.530
66Yoan Moncada3B6335761492487855118412.258.318.463
67DJ LeMahieu2B660600178211069653925.297.354.469
68Yasiel PuigOF5735191372676794612016.264.324.474
69Tommy PhamOF5905111361776687111820.267.356.425
70Luis RobertOF5775301392975673515620.262.307.498
71Max KeplerOF626554145328693631063.262.337.504
72Andrew BenintendiOF6505741581788786512315.275.348.449
73Jeff McNeil2B61955617625908343746.317.366.532
74Justin Turner3B57450115127797657861.301.373.530
75Ketel MarteOF63856915721898062969.277.348.473
76Mike Moustakas2B60754914936769249972.272.331.527
77Mallex SmithOF595537133676454813740.247.308.360
78Khris DavisDH613541130388598611720.240.318.497
79Jorge SolerOF598521134347887661552.258.341.510
80Lourdes Gurriel Jr.OF574529145307982341389.275.319.508
81Eddie RosarioOF616579165309185311054.285.321.500
82Tim AndersonSS6356041652090672514020.274.303.439
83Shohei OhtaniDH5254721292666794713711.274.340.513
84Elvis AndrusSS624577162158167379422.280.324.422
85Nicholas CastellanosOF667611172278993471472.282.333.494
86Oscar MercadoOF5755191361679634611521.262.322.420
87Kyle Seager3B595527131307186591192.249.325.479
88Michael BrantleyOF61655717420838549683.313.368.489
89Jorge PolancoSS660598169219980531125.283.341.461
90Hunter Dozier3B614553145238286551602.262.329.470
91Luke Voit1B539466120287477651460.258.349.486
92Amed RosarioSS6365981591480673213323.265.303.408
93Willson ContrerasC525462122236874531212.264.339.474
94Domingo SantanaOF551489126256977551719.257.332.467
95Paul DeJongSS631565144298882501514.255.316.471
96Yuli Gurriel1B60656316420818430734.291.327.463
97Brandon Lowe2B560505130277483451687.258.318.491
98Didi GregoriusSS57452914930758334803.282.326.511
99Andrew McCutchenOF602515134218569781204.261.358.444
100Byron BuxtonOF4634261091665593211622.256.309.445
101Nomar MazaraOF590534140267987471303.263.323.468
102Eric Hosmer1B655598158218085521442.265.324.429
103Joey Votto1B588489132157868881122.270.382.422
104David Peralta2B604542154218088541272.284.349.475
105Giancarlo StantonOF508433109286782661471.252.351.499
106Daniel Vogelbach1B538453102276676811450.224.342.441
107Franmil ReyesOF551496126327283501540.254.322.492
108Eduardo EscobarOF583527141267680471113.268.327.492
109David DahlOF513468129237679361286.276.327.512
110Hunter RenfroeOF551493113346977501653.230.300.492
111Brian Anderson3B614545145197479551294.266.334.442
112Scott Kingery3B5324871212069613714913.249.302.442
113Shin-Soo ChooOF598514133218160721437.260.350.436
114Will SmithC454402100246367391122.249.315.488
115Teoscar HernandezOF515464113306668461606.244.313.510
116Corey SeagerSS582516140208783581111.272.346.455
117Mitch GarverC499436107226470551200.244.329.456
118Willie CalhounOF54449613929757738920.280.331.515
119Brandon Belt1B566487120197166741254.247.346.432
120Kolten Wong2B567500138116859518518.276.343.415
121Christian WalkerSS576510119277574581555.234.311.444
122Justin UptonOF525453110246779631524.242.334.448
123Adam EatonOF578508140138652589812.277.350.417
124Austin HaysOF498449121246067451058.269.335.481
125Daniel Murphy1B52348014119687737761.295.345.488
126Brett GardnerOF540478119198065541039.250.326.436
127J.D. DavisOF495445123266768451092.276.342.508
128Niko GoodrumSS5604991241775595615112.248.324.432
129Joc PedersonOF488429107317067491071.249.326.525
130Rougned Odor2B5284771092571694214310.229.292.444
131Randal GrichukOF589545133317480351532.244.290.485
132Michael Chavis2B541488125276776461523.256.320.465
133Renato Nunez1B577521129247080461391.247.308.438
134Bryan ReynoldsOF595532146168376541314.274.341.442
135Lorenzo CainOF5955331401180495410716.264.331.384
136Matt Carpenter3B531452108217257691303.238.339.437
137Carlos CorreaSS512446116246974561231.259.342.476
138Danny SantanaOF4794471041967612414417.234.273.432
139Tom MurphyC456421110244862321371.262.314.484
140Yandy Diaz3B50044412418666050903.279.352.472
141Gavin Lux2B524468117206761521269.251.326.447
142Wil MyersOF4514021012058544513112.251.326.460
143Wilson RamosC49545112516527240790.278.336.429
144Kyle TuckerOF38935088165859319715.250.311.454
145Omar NarvaezC45940811019595446920.270.344.449
146Avisail GarciaOF522481134216769311206.279.323.473
147Mark CanhaOF524459115237267521213.251.328.459
148Cesar Hernandez2B592531148137658531019.278.343.412
149Brandon NimmoOF50240395166861851354.235.369.427
150Gregory PolancoOF479430108196566431107.252.320.441
151Dansby SwansonSS582523124157770521349.238.307.386
152Jurickson Profar2B51845811718666449787.255.327.433
153Jean SeguraSS577534152107862356910.285.329.416
154Jason HeywardOF53247312217706353965.259.334.423
155Nick AhmedOF593536135177172471136.251.312.420
156Ian HappOF40935894245650451065.261.343.525
157Tommy Edman2B507464126146856309114.272.317.437
158Willy AdamesSS598545136227567481614.250.310.421
159Freddy GalvisSS607565140227375361525.249.294.425
160Eric Thames1B39634684235255441193.244.328.502
161Mike YastrzemskiOF569509118227373511594.232.302.428
162C.J. Cron1B483441115265267291111.261.306.491
163Corey DickersonOF525488138216264321104.282.326.487
164Evan Longoria3B537483120196272431133.249.311.419
165Ryan McMahon2B479423106196366531344.251.334.445
166Jon BertiSS42238198857383410123.258.318.387
167Zack Cozart3B44038090186061531283.236.329.427
168Dexter FowlerOF544468108176861651307.231.325.400
169Andrelton SimmonsSS552512143126563335011.280.324.409
170Kevin KiernaierOF5024641121563553011516.241.288.413
171Nick Madrigal2B45141312765849342715.307.359.412
172Kevin NewmanSS553517146106159287215.282.318.402
173Salvador PerezC48946111324546618980.245.274.445
174Anthony SantanderOF560521134216777321233.256.299.440
175Shogo AkiyamaOF520464125167156471046.269.336.440
176Evan White1B543506129197164331363.255.300.437
177Maikel Franco3B50045511621566940750.254.314.442
178Carson KellyC4493949516555349991.240.325.419
179Hanser Alberto2B59656516516726324576.293.321.430
180Jesus Aguilar1B467410104215561471170.255.331.455
181Sam HilliardOF40736594235553371145.257.325.518
182Kole CalhounOF502438102216462551203.233.319.429
183Jackie Bradley Jr.OF502447107196458451257.240.310.429
184Christian VazquezC44340510416535231892.256.309.426
185Adam Frazier2B58953815212795941775.283.334.429
186Asdrubal Cabrera3B44839910617555643903.265.336.448
187Starlin Castro2B591548153176871351062.279.323.430
188Travis d'ArnaudC459416101185158341011.244.301.430
189Jarrod DysonOF3943458155031437123.235.321.328
190Alex VerdugoOF51546612915626241775.276.335.440
191Franchy CorderoOF413373911449453712814.244.313.435
192Gio Urshela3B49545712217626330941.268.312.439
193Jorge AlfaroC460424103185059231433.243.282.420
194Ender InciarteOF47242311186442427614.262.329.383
195Dylan CarlsonOF39735891154946369112.255.322.443
196Miguel Andujar3B41839210919565921751.279.315.496
197Buster PoseyC48543611710535144701.270.336.395
198Aristides AquinoOF40236385215460321215.234.296.459
199Luis UriasSS539480124156757491025.259.327.406
200Nico HoernerSS46041211412685444695.275.345.418
201Yadier MolinaC44541211013495422583.267.304.410
202Albert Pujols1B48243710718477039671.245.307.415
203Reese McGuireC3623308815464129652.267.326.465
204Jonathan Schoop2B518481125246564261241.260.298.465
205Robinson ChirinosC42736681164754471281.222.310.406
206Carter KieboomSS486431109176157491224.252.328.423
207Miguel Cabrera1B541481131135162541030.272.346.394
208Kevin PillarOF493464121156253207411.260.291.425
209Mauricio Dubon2B486456125125754248311.273.310.414
210Mike TauchmanOF40235186125457481005.246.337.418
211Roberto PerezC45640284184355481320.210.294.391
212Mitch Moreland1B4253779318485742931.247.323.453
213J.P. CrawfordSS519455106116162571196.234.319.384
214Kurt SuzukiC3333028417414420400.279.323.499
215Yoshitomo TsutsugoOF506451113186160511160.252.327.426
216Jesse WinkerOF3933449917534743591.287.367.493
217Howie Kendrick2B39235610916555327632.305.355.514
218David Fletcher2B5755251486755246636.281.339.381
219Nick SolakDH4083569914554841825.277.351.465
220Josh RojasOF35831880114337367914.252.328.428
221Brian Dozier2B4323759018544852914.241.333.439
222Jeimer Candelario3B49042697135654541223.227.314.388
223Robinson Cano2B51246412717615941770.274.333.453
224A.J. PollockOF3923569416545127785.265.317.467
225Tucker BarnhartC4353829312395048911.244.328.391
226Luis Arraez2B5314721415704853484.298.369.391
227Justin Smoak1B3683127517434651850.242.349.455
228Jason CastroC40335380144748441210.226.312.395
229Ryon Healy3B441409104194861261010.253.298.441
230Hunter PenceOF3673339016484729815.271.330.477
231Sean MurphyC42037087115050421011.235.313.385
232Francisco MejiaC3553248215434324822.252.303.455
233Stephen PiscottyOF46942210817596137941.256.317.433
234Ryan BraunOF3723408915495426826.261.314.459
235Austin RileyOF37434085215259261081.249.303.485
236Marwin Gonzalez3B4083709614515233901.259.319.435
237Brian GoodwinOF40135989155244361087.248.317.445
238Brandon CrawfordSS558499121145963501173.242.311.380
239Adam HaseleyOF40736910214484633775.277.336.447
240Scooter Gennett2B459424117155957281062.275.319.447
241Todd Frazier3B3933458418464935902.243.313.444
242Chance SiscoC39633878144644401111.232.312.406
243Dee Gordon2B44841711534934226320.276.313.358
244Delino DeshieldsOF3673267944726378820.244.320.336
245Jose MartinezOF40236110215515036842.282.347.457
246Steven Souza Jr.C2852505812313431845.233.319.442
247Wilmer FloresOF41638211017535225500.288.331.492
248Tommy La Stella2B46142311915585432510.282.333.439
249Ji-Man Choi1B3803268214414646871.253.344.430
250Garrett Hampson2B3383088184632278614.261.321.414

For all the rankings, strategy, and analysis you could ever want, check out the 2020 FantraxHQ Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit. We’ll be adding more content from now right up until Opening Day!


Fantrax was one of the fastest-growing fantasy sites of 2019 and we’re not letting our foot off the pedal now! With multi-team trades, designated commissioner/league managers, and drag/drop easy click methods, Fantrax is sure to excite the serious fantasy sports fan – sign up now for a free year at Fantrax.com.

3 Comments
  1. Aaron says

    How is Mondesi #14 with that obp?

    1. Doug Anderson says

      Yeah, I wondered when someone would see that. He’s projected at 49 SB and that works out to almost 14 SGP (Standings Gains Points). I also used a 15-team league in computing these values so the replacement level OBP was lower… With that said, I’m not drafting him that high in an OBP league. Those 49 SBs are probably the very top end and if he doesn’t reach that his OBP which does carry negative value will have to be absorbed by the rest of your lineup. These are the pure numbers spit out by a formula. You don’t have to follow it. I know I won’t in this case. It does, however, demonstrate how valuable those stolen bases can be if he does indeed get anywhere near 50.

  2. Prte says

    A lot of your players on the first 50 list are no longer on major league rosters!

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.