When an organization parts with a franchise player, the return is judged not by replacing one superstar but by how many future contributors emerge from the deal. Baltimore’s decision to move All-Star catcher Adley Rutschman signals a shift toward its next competitive cycle, and the package it received reflects a balanced approach: immediate major league help, high-end pitching talent, and long-term upside.
Dynasty Baseball Trade Report: Inside Baltimore’s New Farm System and Evaluating the Talent Acquired in the Adley Rutschman Blockbuster
Here’s a closer look at each player joining the Orioles organization.
Anthony Eyanson (RHP):Â Your Potential Future Ace!
Fantasy Grade: ★★★★★ (ETA 2027)
Overall Evaluation
Eyanson arrives as the centerpiece of Baltimore’s return and projects as one of the organization’s top pitching prospects. His game is built around polish, command, and the ability to miss bats without sacrificing efficiency.
His fastball generally operates in the mid-90s with enough life to generate swings underneath the baseball. The slider is his signature pitch, consistently producing chase swings and weak contact. A developing changeup has taken meaningful steps forward and gives him another weapon against left-handed hitters.
What separates Eyanson from many young pitchers is his advanced feel for sequencing and attacking hitters. Rather than relying solely on velocity, he changes eye levels, works both sides of the plate, and rarely falls behind in counts.
Strengths
- Advanced command
- Three quality pitches
- Efficient strike thrower
- Projects to handle a starter’s workload
Development Goals
- Continue refining the changeup
- Add consistency deeper into games
Fantasy Ceiling
- No. 2 fantasy starter with occasional SP1 seasons
- 180–200 innings annually
- 190–220 strikeouts
- Above-average WHIP and ERA due to excellent command
- High floor thanks to durability and pitchability
Major League Projection
Eyanson profiles as a dependable top-of-the-rotation starter capable of logging significant innings while generating above-average strikeout totals.
Kyson Witherspoon (RHP): A Strikeout Machine
Fantasy Grade: ★★★★☆ (ETA 2028)
Overall Evaluation
Where Eyanson wins with polish, Witherspoon wins with raw stuff.
His fastball features premium velocity and enough movement to overpower hitters when located. The slider flashes as a legitimate out pitch with sharp late break, while both his curveball and changeup continue to develop into complementary offerings.
The next step in his development is improving consistency from start to start. When his delivery stays in rhythm, he looks every bit like a future impact starter. If the command never fully reaches that level, his arsenal would still allow him to become an elite high-leverage reliever.
Strengths
- Plus velocity
- Swing-and-miss breaking ball
- Athletic frame
- High strikeout potential
Development Goals
- Improve fastball location
- Increase overall pitch efficiency
- Refine secondary offerings
Fantasy Ceiling
- No. 2–3 fantasy starter if command reaches its potential
- Strikeout-per-inning upside (200+ K capability over a full season)
- Fastball/slider combination gives him ace-level weekly upside
- If starting doesn’t stick, he possesses the arsenal to become an elite fantasy closer capable of 30+ saves
Major League Projection
Witherspoon has the upside to develop into a No. 2 or strong No. 3 starter with occasional frontline performances.
Enddy Azocar (OF): A 5–Tool Player in the Making?
Fantasy Grade: ★★★★☆ (ETA 2029)
Overall Evaluation
Azocar represents the longest-term investment in the trade, but perhaps one of its most intriguing.
An athletic center fielder with above-average speed, he covers plenty of ground defensively and shows encouraging instincts in all phases of the game. Offensively, his quick hands and developing approach provide optimism that additional strength could unlock more extra-base production over the next several seasons.
Because of his age, patience will be required, but the foundation of an everyday player is already visible.
Strengths
- Athleticism
- Defensive versatility
- Speed
- High developmental ceiling
Development Goals
- Add strength
- Improve plate discipline
- Convert raw power into game production
Fantasy Ceiling
- .275–.285 batting average
- 18–22 home runs
- 25–35 stolen bases
- 85+ runs scored, hitting near the top of the lineup
- Top-25 fantasy outfielder with strong five-category production
Major League Projection
Projects as a potential everyday center fielder whose value could come from defense, speed, and an improving offensive game. Only time will tell. But one thing is certain. Azocar, at his young age, is already a huge up arrow prospect. So, stash him before everyone catches on!
Final Thoughts
Viewed strictly through a scouting lens, Baltimore secured a package that balances present value with future potential.
Eyanson provides the highest probability of becoming an impact major league starter, while Witherspoon offers one of the highest ceilings in the deal. Azocar gives the organization another athletic prospect capable of developing into an everyday player over time.
From a dynasty fantasy baseball perspective, Baltimore may have quietly added three players with legitimate long-term value, even if none are immediate contributors.
Anthony Eyanson is the clear prize of the package, combining a high floor with frontline fantasy upside thanks to his command, strikeout potential, and ability to work deep into games.
Kyson Witherspoon offers the highest risk and reward profile. His electric fastball and bat-missing slider give him the ingredients to become a high-strikeout fantasy starter, but his long-term value will depend on whether he develops enough command to remain in the rotation.
Enddy Azocar is the player dynasty managers should stash with patience. His athleticism, speed, and defensive ability provide a solid foundation, and if his bat continues to develop, he has the tools to become a five-category fantasy contributor.
No trade involving a franchise catcher will ever be easy to evaluate in the short term. However, if Baltimore successfully develops its two young pitchers and Azocar reaches his offensive potential, this return could ultimately be remembered as the foundation of the club’s next competitive core.
Fantrax is one of the fastest-growing fantasy sites in the fantasy sports industry, and we’re not stopping anytime soon. We are the most customizable, easy-to-use, and feature-rich platform in the industry, offering the greatest fantasy experience for your dynasty, keeper, redraft, and best ball leagues. Fantasy sports doesn’t sleep, and neither does Fantrax, with seasons running 365 days a year. Take your fantasy leagues to the next level now at Fantrax.com!
